Love it or Hate it…
March 10th, 2010 | Published in Uncategorized
Marmite: love the product or hate it (I hate it), you can’t help but be taken in by a brand that’ not only to acknowledges that it can’t please everyone, but turns that fact into a marketing coup. Now, as they unleash their latest gastronomic monstrosity in the form of a cereal bar with a yeasty shock in the middle, Marmite are asking us, the public, if we feel that they have gone “too far”.
I bring up the dreaded but fascinating spread, not to answer their question (the answer is “yes”), nor to analyse the efficacy of suggesting to potential customers that your product may, in fact, be disgusting. I am using Marmite as a rare exemplar of a campaign that actually lends itself to everyone’s favourite bandwagon, social media.
Marmite is the second UK brand to use Facebook’s new sampling ad format. The ads, which pop-up from users’ news-feeds, do not drive potential customers to a website or profile but instead prompt them to accept a free sample, become a fan and declare their undying love or hate. Thus, Marmite informs the potential customer of its new product, acquires their mailing address and the right to use their news-feed as an interactive billboard to advertise to all their friends. All in the guise of a one-question survey with a free cereal bar at the end.
This three-birds-with-one-stone quality is essential to Facebook’s utility. Rather than creating and maintaining a purpose-built website, and worrying about search optimisation and the arduous task of actually updating the site; make a cookie-cutter profile for your product, use one of the many pre-existing applications designed to filter your pen-portrait customer from the 25 million Brits who have volunteered every conceivable detail of themselves, and all you have to do is remember to feed it with fresh content now-and-then.
Now that product fan pages support status updates, videos, a “wall”, games and all the dynamic, interactive features that are de rigueur on people’s personal profiles, keeping the things alive is easier than ever. What’s more, every new development is broadcast via members’ news-feeds, an invaluable viral opportunity if seized upon. “John Hates Marmite: tell him why he’s wrong and while you’re at it give us your mailing address”.

The trouble with attempts by large corporations to get with the cool kids and seek out their custom is that most cool kids don’t want to be sought. They resent patronising advertisers ‘tricking’ them into participating in their campaigns, and everyone hates spam. The trick, as I see it, is making your move so quick and unobtrusive and so natural in the context of Facebook, that it seems more like an off-hand remark than an all-day seminar.
The idea is to move on-line marketing away from driving customers to a static website, which is really just an electronic brochure, towards a one-on-one, back-and-forth “conversation” between a brand and its customers. Ideally, all we’ll have to do is log into Facebook and every brand that thinks it stands a chance will come looking for us to ask a question, offer advice or draw our attention to something cool.
That’s the strength of Marmite’s campaign; it has a pre-established “in”, a controversy. Its incursion doesn’t feel forced. Browsing the news you notice a friend has said the wrong thing about what to have on your toast, you correct him and sign-up for a free cereal bar, and the good news spreads to all you other friends. No nonsense, no fuss. So while other brands are regarded as nuisances, we will all be friends (or enemies) of Marmite.
John McIntosh
Last 5 posts by admin
- Baber Smith Get Waisted - April 1st, 2010
- A Little book of ideas for everyone... - February 8th, 2010
- What do Baber Smithians want for Christmas… - December 24th, 2009
- SAY IT AIN'T MO! - December 1st, 2009
- Taking our expertise ... everywhere. - September 28th, 2009








Sam Jordan: Loves marketing, business (runs this one) and learning about people. Likes stuff and doing things. Knows he’s lucky to have found a vocation that constantly brings new challenges.
Mark Blanchard: A man who's been using his abiding passion for words to sell a wide variety of products and services for many years.
Diana Hopfner: Multilingual, Account Exec, Diana balances her sweet tooth with an extreme early rise attitude and exercise addiction.
Emma Blanchard: Loves fashion and ballet. So far so girly. Also loves football and boxing. Go figure!
Sarah_Jean Duggan: A smart, enthusiastic young copywriter. An Essex Girl who makes Essex Girl jokes redundant.
Jo Smith: Less Margaret Thatcher, more Joan of Arc. Jo is an experienced and entrepreneurial marketer having held the roles of Business Development Director and Sales and Marketing Director at agencies such as Bates, Leo Burnett, Saatchi & Saatchi and Grey prior to finding a decent job at Baber Smith!
Oliver Sherwell: A account handler by day and devourer of all that is digital and creatively inspiring by night.
John McIntosh : New to Baber Smith fresh from Edinburgh code named John McWiki. A man with an encyclopaedic brain - they say advertising isn’t rocket science but he could actually be a rocket scientist.
Baber Smith Interns: They come with boundless enthusiasm, unquenchable passion and a pure willingness to learn .Our interns may only be at Baber Smith for a short while but we’re happy to let them share our part of the blogosphere.